When it comes to changing a tire, having the right tools is essential. Two tools that can come in handy are the Tyre Key and Tyre Pliers. But which one is the better option for you? In this comparison, we will take a closer look at the pros and cons of each tool and find out which one comes out on top.
Overview - Tyre Key works by using a traditional tyre lever on one end to help remove the tyre and a hook to go over the top of the tyre when coming to the final tight section when re installing. The hook clips under the tyre and when applying force is pulled back onto the rim.
Tyre Pliers are designed in a similar way, they pinch the top of tight wheels and pull the tight section back over the rim.
Design: Which tool has a more versatile design?
The Tyre key comes with a standard tyre lever on one end, which is straightforward to use and helps take tires off. On the other end, it has a round top that hooks over the wheel and clamps under the final tight bit of tyre when installing it. The tyre pliers, on the other hand, only have one purpose - to help you put the tire back on the wheel. They clip under the tyre and use force from the opposite side to pull the tyre onto the rim.
Ease of use: Which tool is easier to use?
The tyre lever on the Tyre key is straightforward to use and is similar than a traditional tire lever. The round top hook on the Tyre key, however, can be difficult to get it clipped under the tyre to re-install, especially if you're not used to it. The tyre pliers, on the other hand, can be difficult to use at first, and can cause the tyre to slip if the tool is not anchored correctly on the rim.
In the Workshop: Which tool is more practical for workshop use?
In a workshop setting, the Tyre key can be useful, but it only works on road bike tyres. If you have a range of different bikes, you'll need the assistance of other tools to get the job done. The tyre pliers can also be useful, especially for tight-fitting tyres, but they're unable to remove tires, so assistance from other tyre levers will be needed.
At the Roadside: Which tool is more practical for roadside use?
The Tyre key is small and flat, making it easy to take with you on the road. However, it will only work on road bikes and may also need other levers to help. The tyre pliers, on the other hand, are too big to take out on the road and only serve one purpose.
Size and Weight: Which tool is more compact and lightweight?
| Tool | Length (cm) | Height (cm) | Width (cm) | Weight (g) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tyre Key | 14 | 7 | 0.75 | 34 |
| Tyre Pliers | 22.5 | 6 | 2 | 116 |
As we can see from the table above, the Tyre Key is significantly more compact and lightweight than the Tyre pliers. This makes it more suitable to carry with you and store.
Overall Winner: So, which tool comes out on top?
For me, the Tyre key is the overall winner. It has a more versatile design and is easier to use. It's also more practical for roadside use, and it's more compact and lightweight. However, the tyre pliers can be useful in a workshop setting for tight-fitting tires. So, it depends on what you're looking for in a tire tool and your personal preferences. However with both tools you are still required to use your hands to install the majority of the tyre.
In conclusion, changing a tire can be a pain, but with the right tools, it doesn't have to be. The Tyre key and Tyre pliers are both valuable tools to have in your arsenal, but the Tyre key is the clear winner when it comes to versatility, ease of use, and portability.
